International Journal of
Reproductive Biomedicine
Thu, Nov 21, 2024
[Archive]
Volume 20, Issue 12 (December 2022)
IJRM 2022, 20(12): 1039-1046 |
Back to browse issues page
Download citation:
BibTeX | RIS | EndNote | Medlars | ProCite | Reference Manager | RefWorks
Send citation to:
BibTeX | RIS | EndNote | Medlars | ProCite | Reference Manager | RefWorks
Send citation to:
Shafii M, Madadizadeh F, Askari R, Zarezadeh M, Abdoli A M, Bahariniya S. Investigating medical tourism development indicators in Yazd Reproductive Sciences Institute: A cross-sectional study. IJRM 2022; 20 (12) :1039-1046
URL: http://ijrm.ir/article-1-2513-en.html
URL: http://ijrm.ir/article-1-2513-en.html
Milad Shafii1 
, Farzan Madadizadeh2 , Roohollah Askari1 , Mohammad Zarezadeh1 , Ali Mohamad Abdoli3 , Sajjad Bahariniya * 4
, Farzan Madadizadeh2 , Roohollah Askari1 , Mohammad Zarezadeh1 , Ali Mohamad Abdoli3 , Sajjad Bahariniya * 4
1- Department of Health Services Management, Health Policy and Management Research Center, School of Public Health, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran.
2- Center for Healthcare Data Modeling, Departments of Biostatistics and Epidemiology, School of Public Health, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran.
3- Research and Clinical Center for Infertility, Yazd Reproductive Sciences Institute, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran.
4- Department of Health Services Management, Health Policy and Management Research Center, School of Public Health, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran. ,sajjadbahari98@gmail.com
2- Center for Healthcare Data Modeling, Departments of Biostatistics and Epidemiology, School of Public Health, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran.
3- Research and Clinical Center for Infertility, Yazd Reproductive Sciences Institute, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran.
4- Department of Health Services Management, Health Policy and Management Research Center, School of Public Health, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran. ,
Full-Text [PDF 273 kb]
(626 Downloads)
| Abstract (HTML) (795 Views)
Full-Text: (128 Views)
- Introduction
Medical tourism (MT) is growing at a breakneck pace and its potential can significantly contribute to nations' sustainable development and economic growth (1, 2). MT refers to the process by which individuals go to another city or nation to get nonemergency medical interventions that are unavailable, delayed, unprofessional, or too costly in their country of residence. According to applied research, the following factors contribute to individual motivations for engaging in MT: long waiting times, high costs, overcrowding, an insufficient number of healthcare professionals, and sophisticated technological equipment (3). The most common approaches of medical tourists are as follows: dental treatment, cosmetic surgery, orthopedic therapies, organ transplantation, and infertility treatment (4).
Investing in the MT sector is a strategy to increase gross domestic product, improve services, earn foreign currency, create a better trade balance, and improve the tourism industry (5). Health tourism is already a $100 billion business worldwide, and this part of tourism is currently enjoying an average increase of 25% (6). MT has a direct relationship with the health of medical tourists and is therefore very sensitive. Currently, many countries provide MT services only to earn money, while the nature of MT is different from other types of tourism and more potential is needed (7). Meeting the expectations of medical tourists and considering more benefits than treatment costs can lead to the success and development of MT (8).
Some studies have been conducted to assess the state of MT development indicators and to identify variables affecting the industry's growth (9, 10). The most critical dimensions of MT included: financial services, quality of medical services, political factors, information, attitudes of doctors and specialists in the field of healthcare and cultural factors (11). In a study, the factors affecting the attractiveness of MT in India were examined and it was concluded that the main reason for becoming a strong MT destination is because of its specialized and high-quality medical services at an affordable price .Researchers in this study judged service quality as a vital factor in MT that significantly affects patient satisfaction (12).
Although Yazd is a capable center in the field of infertility in Iran and across the world, there are no necessary tourism infrastructure services and facilities for tourists. Considering the importance of the above issue, this research was conducted to investigate the status of current MT development indicators at Yazd Reproductive Sciences Institute, Yazd, Iran.
Investing in the MT sector is a strategy to increase gross domestic product, improve services, earn foreign currency, create a better trade balance, and improve the tourism industry (5). Health tourism is already a $100 billion business worldwide, and this part of tourism is currently enjoying an average increase of 25% (6). MT has a direct relationship with the health of medical tourists and is therefore very sensitive. Currently, many countries provide MT services only to earn money, while the nature of MT is different from other types of tourism and more potential is needed (7). Meeting the expectations of medical tourists and considering more benefits than treatment costs can lead to the success and development of MT (8).
Some studies have been conducted to assess the state of MT development indicators and to identify variables affecting the industry's growth (9, 10). The most critical dimensions of MT included: financial services, quality of medical services, political factors, information, attitudes of doctors and specialists in the field of healthcare and cultural factors (11). In a study, the factors affecting the attractiveness of MT in India were examined and it was concluded that the main reason for becoming a strong MT destination is because of its specialized and high-quality medical services at an affordable price .Researchers in this study judged service quality as a vital factor in MT that significantly affects patient satisfaction (12).
Although Yazd is a capable center in the field of infertility in Iran and across the world, there are no necessary tourism infrastructure services and facilities for tourists. Considering the importance of the above issue, this research was conducted to investigate the status of current MT development indicators at Yazd Reproductive Sciences Institute, Yazd, Iran.
- Materials and Methods
This cross-sectional study examined the state of MT development indicators at Yazd Reproductive Sciences Institute, Yazd, Iran in 2021 (for 9 months from February to November 2021). 430 internal medical tourists by convenience sampling were included in this study. The most important criterion for entering this study was that tourists who refer to the infertility research center for treatment should be examined. Local people or non-tourists were excluded. In fact, only people outside of Yazd province were investigated and people from other cities of the province were not included in the study. In fact, only people outside of Yazd province were investigated and people from other cities of the province were not included in the study. If a person was originally from another city, but lived in Yazd for several years, that person was not considered a tourist. On the other hand, if a person is originally from Yazd but has lived in another city for several years, that person is considered a tourist. All participants were asked to fill a researcher-made questionnaire with 46 questions and 10 dimensions in both internal (factors inside the medical center) and external (factors outside the medical center) environments.
To make a questionnaire in the first phase, essential information was extracted from previous Persian and English studies (450 studies). These studies were extracted from various databases such as Scopus, PubMed, Science Direct, Web of Science, SID, Google Scholar, and others. The Delphi method was used to gather expert opinions. For this purpose, 3 phases of the Delphi method were used, so that in each phase, the importance of the variables was measured from the point of view of healthcare professionals, health policy makers, tourism managers, MT experts, and faculty members of Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd. Face validity and content validity were evaluated. For content validity, the content validity ratio and content validity index were calculated (overall content validity index= 0.85). In construct validity questions were classified, and scale dimensions were determined through exploratory factor analysis. Then, the accuracy of this analysis was evaluated using confirmatory factor analysis. For validity assessment of the questionnaire, internal consistency and stability reliability were calculated. For internal consistency, Cronbach's alpha was 0.817 for this questionnaire. For stability reliability, the questionnaire's intra-cluster correlation coefficient was 0.779. The questionnaire contained 46 questions with 10 dimension {medical services (11 questions), human resources (6 questions), administrative and financial services (5 questions), support services (3 questions), information (3 questions), advertising and marketing (4 questions), economic factors (3 questions), cultural and political factors (5 questions), geographical and environmental factors (3 questions), and tourism industry infrastructure (3 questions)}. This 5-point Likert questionnaire included 5 response options (strongly agree, agree, have no opinion, disagree, and strongly disagree). The working method was that the scores of the questions of each item were added together and finally a comparison was made. The researcher asked the participants to complete the questionnaires.
To make a questionnaire in the first phase, essential information was extracted from previous Persian and English studies (450 studies). These studies were extracted from various databases such as Scopus, PubMed, Science Direct, Web of Science, SID, Google Scholar, and others. The Delphi method was used to gather expert opinions. For this purpose, 3 phases of the Delphi method were used, so that in each phase, the importance of the variables was measured from the point of view of healthcare professionals, health policy makers, tourism managers, MT experts, and faculty members of Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd. Face validity and content validity were evaluated. For content validity, the content validity ratio and content validity index were calculated (overall content validity index= 0.85). In construct validity questions were classified, and scale dimensions were determined through exploratory factor analysis. Then, the accuracy of this analysis was evaluated using confirmatory factor analysis. For validity assessment of the questionnaire, internal consistency and stability reliability were calculated. For internal consistency, Cronbach's alpha was 0.817 for this questionnaire. For stability reliability, the questionnaire's intra-cluster correlation coefficient was 0.779. The questionnaire contained 46 questions with 10 dimension {medical services (11 questions), human resources (6 questions), administrative and financial services (5 questions), support services (3 questions), information (3 questions), advertising and marketing (4 questions), economic factors (3 questions), cultural and political factors (5 questions), geographical and environmental factors (3 questions), and tourism industry infrastructure (3 questions)}. This 5-point Likert questionnaire included 5 response options (strongly agree, agree, have no opinion, disagree, and strongly disagree). The working method was that the scores of the questions of each item were added together and finally a comparison was made. The researcher asked the participants to complete the questionnaires.
2.1. Sample size
Using the Cochran prevalence sample size formula, by considering the prevalence of infertile women equal to 50%, and the significance level of 5%, an error rate of 5%, and the power test of 80%, the initial sample size was estimated to be 384, which considering a 10% chance of nonresponse rate, the final sample size was considered to be 430. The sample size was calculated based on a similar study (13).
2.2. Ethical considerations
The proposal of the present study was approved by the Ethics Committee of Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran (Code: IR.SSU.SPH.REC.1399.170). The informed consent form were obtained from all participants following the explanation about the goal of the study.
2.3. Statistical analysis
Social package Sciences statistical v. 24 (SPSS, Inc, Chicago, IL) was used to perform all statistical analyses. Quantitative data were reported as mean ± standard deviation, median, minimum, maximum, and frequency (percentage). The Spearman tests were also used to assess the correlation between the quantitative factors. A p-value < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
2.3. Statistical analysis
Social package Sciences statistical v. 24 (SPSS, Inc, Chicago, IL) was used to perform all statistical analyses. Quantitative data were reported as mean ± standard deviation, median, minimum, maximum, and frequency (percentage). The Spearman tests were also used to assess the correlation between the quantitative factors. A p-value < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
- Results
Initially, 500 participants were eligible to enter the study. Out of them, 70 tourists were excluded due to lack of accuracy in completing the questionnaire. Finally, the data of 430 participants were analysed (Table I).
52.6% (n = 226) of participants were aged between 30-40 yr. The number of women was more than men (62.1%). 52.1% had the experience of a previous trip to Yazd. 40.7% knew this medical center through their doctor. The demographic characteristics of participants were shown in table I.
The descriptive statistics of MT development in the field of infertility based on the dimensions of the questionnaire was shown in table II.
The mean score of developmental indices in the internal environment was 139.21 ± 8.05, the mean total score of developmental indices in the external environment was 54.95 ± 4.37, and the mean score of the total questionnaire was 194.17 ± 10.45.
The descriptive statistics for MT development indicators were presented in table III. Our results indicated that medical services, human resources, administrative and financial services, support services, information, cultural and political factors, and geographical and environmental factors were all "very good."
The correlation between indicators of the internal and external environment was calculated using Spearman's correlation coefficient and showed that the correlation between these dimensions was significant and weak (r = 0.349 , p < 0.001).
Administrative and financial services were another significant predictive factor of the internal environment. The situation of administrative and financial services of Yazd Reproductive Sciences Research Institute was evaluated as very good. This demonstrates the medical center's clarity and comprehensibility in all stages, the acceptability of tourism payment methods, the transparency of medical tariff rates for internal patients, and the tolerance of tourist medical visit costs. In a study, researchers emphasized the critical role of financial services in attracting medical tourists and argued that when healthcare costs increase, tourists face more financial risks and, ultimately, a lower rate of return. The number of visitors returning to the appropriate medical facilities is reduced (19). The findings of these studies confirm the current findings. The state of advertising and marketing in the domestic environment was evaluated as good. This might mean that the experienced personnel educates visitors about the facilities in this medical institution via face-to-face interactions, brochures or booklets, social media, and user-friendly websites. Similar studies by researchers, underlined the need for health authorities and managers to pay particular attention to the advertising and marketing index as an effective indicator of MT growth (20, 21) this research confirms the findings of the present study.
Economic, cultural, political, geographical, environmental factors, and tourism industry infrastructure were all investigated in the external environment. In the meantime, economic factors were assessed as good. This may indicate cost-effective travel to Yazd city, cost-effective accommodation, and recreation. Researchers also identified economic factors as an external factor affecting the growth of MT (22). One of the influential indicators in the external environment was the tourism industry infrastructure. This external index was evaluated as unfavorable compared to other indicators studied in the present study. It seems that the lack of a suitable website to meet the needs of health tourists, the lack of relaxing places to rest after receiving medical services, the lack of special centers to help health tourists, and the lack of adequate urban facilities are the most significant reasons for the inefficiency of this index. In a study, the major elements affecting the growth of MT in Turkey were evaluated and it was concluded that strategic marketing road maps should prioritize economic considerations and tourist infrastructure (23). The findings of this research confirm the findings current.
Managers of Yazd Reproductive Sciences Institute should pay close attention to the advertising and marketing index and make necessary plans. On the other hand, one of the ways to influence the attractiveness of MT and tourists' decisions to visit Yazd as a tourism destination is the tourism industry's infrastructure. Provincial senior managers should increase the demand for health tourism by enhancing the tourism industry's infrastructure index and adequate urban facilities.
Acknowledgments
This study is the result of part of the research thesis and was supported by Yazd Reproductive Sciences Institute and the Research Council of the Faculty of Health, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran (grant no: 8895).
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.
52.6% (n = 226) of participants were aged between 30-40 yr. The number of women was more than men (62.1%). 52.1% had the experience of a previous trip to Yazd. 40.7% knew this medical center through their doctor. The demographic characteristics of participants were shown in table I.
The descriptive statistics of MT development in the field of infertility based on the dimensions of the questionnaire was shown in table II.
The mean score of developmental indices in the internal environment was 139.21 ± 8.05, the mean total score of developmental indices in the external environment was 54.95 ± 4.37, and the mean score of the total questionnaire was 194.17 ± 10.45.
The descriptive statistics for MT development indicators were presented in table III. Our results indicated that medical services, human resources, administrative and financial services, support services, information, cultural and political factors, and geographical and environmental factors were all "very good."
The correlation between indicators of the internal and external environment was calculated using Spearman's correlation coefficient and showed that the correlation between these dimensions was significant and weak (r = 0.349 , p < 0.001).
4. Discussion
Medical services were one of the key indicators investigated in the internal environment. The following medical services in this center were fully assessed: a short wait for services, the availability of high-quality specialized medical services, the presence of advanced medical facilities and equipment, comprehensive medical services, new medical techniques and methods, patient privacy, dignity and respect, the confidentiality of medical tourist information and records, and providing the essential para clinical services. In a study, researchers emphasized the important role of medical services in the growth of MT and the necessity of expanding high-tech medical services in Thailand (14). Also, other studies emphasized the importance of providing high-tech medical services as a factor in the growth of MT and increasing visitors’ loyalty to MT (15, 16). The results of these studies confirm the findings of the present study on medical services. Human resource is another important factor for determining how the internal environment was evaluated in this center. Appropriate grading of human resources in this center can indicate the physician's high level of knowledge and skill, the physician's high level of credibility and international reputation, the physician's high level of professional responsibility and commitment, the presence of experienced and trained physicians and personnel, the physician's ability to communicate with medical tourists and the staff's appropriate behavior. A study showed that an effective workforce can be a critical factor in determining the growth of MT in Indonesia (17). In another study, researchers examined the policies promoting MT in South Korea, to develop human resource management guidelines for the MT industry based on the operational realities to ensure the availability of professional and trained human resources (18). These studies confirm the conclusions of the current study findings. Administrative and financial services were another significant predictive factor of the internal environment. The situation of administrative and financial services of Yazd Reproductive Sciences Research Institute was evaluated as very good. This demonstrates the medical center's clarity and comprehensibility in all stages, the acceptability of tourism payment methods, the transparency of medical tariff rates for internal patients, and the tolerance of tourist medical visit costs. In a study, researchers emphasized the critical role of financial services in attracting medical tourists and argued that when healthcare costs increase, tourists face more financial risks and, ultimately, a lower rate of return. The number of visitors returning to the appropriate medical facilities is reduced (19). The findings of these studies confirm the current findings. The state of advertising and marketing in the domestic environment was evaluated as good. This might mean that the experienced personnel educates visitors about the facilities in this medical institution via face-to-face interactions, brochures or booklets, social media, and user-friendly websites. Similar studies by researchers, underlined the need for health authorities and managers to pay particular attention to the advertising and marketing index as an effective indicator of MT growth (20, 21) this research confirms the findings of the present study.
Economic, cultural, political, geographical, environmental factors, and tourism industry infrastructure were all investigated in the external environment. In the meantime, economic factors were assessed as good. This may indicate cost-effective travel to Yazd city, cost-effective accommodation, and recreation. Researchers also identified economic factors as an external factor affecting the growth of MT (22). One of the influential indicators in the external environment was the tourism industry infrastructure. This external index was evaluated as unfavorable compared to other indicators studied in the present study. It seems that the lack of a suitable website to meet the needs of health tourists, the lack of relaxing places to rest after receiving medical services, the lack of special centers to help health tourists, and the lack of adequate urban facilities are the most significant reasons for the inefficiency of this index. In a study, the major elements affecting the growth of MT in Turkey were evaluated and it was concluded that strategic marketing road maps should prioritize economic considerations and tourist infrastructure (23). The findings of this research confirm the findings current.
Managers of Yazd Reproductive Sciences Institute should pay close attention to the advertising and marketing index and make necessary plans. On the other hand, one of the ways to influence the attractiveness of MT and tourists' decisions to visit Yazd as a tourism destination is the tourism industry's infrastructure. Provincial senior managers should increase the demand for health tourism by enhancing the tourism industry's infrastructure index and adequate urban facilities.
Acknowledgments
This study is the result of part of the research thesis and was supported by Yazd Reproductive Sciences Institute and the Research Council of the Faculty of Health, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran (grant no: 8895).
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.
Type of Study: Original Article |
Subject:
Pregnancy Health
References
1. 1. Jiang L, Wu H, Song Y. Diversified demand for health tourism matters: From a perspective of the intra-industry trade. Soc Sci Med 2022; 293: 114630.
2. 2. Sukjai P, Srirak C. Cross-border medical tourism of tourists in Thailand’s border provinces: A case study of Laotian tourists in Nongkhai and Udon Thani Patthaphon. Kasetsart Journal of Social Sciences 2022; 43: 123-130.
3. 3. Bulatovic I, Iankova K. Barriers to medical tourism development in the United Arab Emirates (UAE). Int J Environ Res Public Health 2021; 18: 1365.
4. 4. Béland D, Zarzeczny A. Medical tourism and national health care systems: An institutionalist research agenda. Global Health 2018; 14: 68.
5. 5. Skountridaki L. Barriers to business relations between medical tourism facilitators and medical professionals. Tourism Management 2017; 59: 254-266.
6. 6. Suess C, Baloglu S, Busser JA. Perceived impacts of medical tourism development on community wellbeing. Tourism Management 2018; 69: 232-245.
7. 7. Lee TJ, Han J-S, Ko T-G. Health-oriented tourists and sustainable domestic tourism. Sustainability 2020; 12: 4988.
8. 8. Vovk V, Beztelesna L, Pliashko O. Identification of factors for the development of medical tourism in the world. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2021; 18: 11205.
9. 9. Aiwerioghene EM, Singh M, Ajmera P. Modelling the factors affecting Nigerian medical tourism sector using an interpretive structural modelling approach. Int J Healthcare Management 2021; 14: 563-575.
10. 10. Chia KW, Liao YM. An exploratory study of factors influencing Chinese outbound medical tourism. J China Tourism Res 2021; 17: 376-394.
11. 11. Najjari H, Didehkhani H, Mostaghimi M, Hosseini SM. [Identifying and prioritizing the dimensions of medical tourism with emphasis on technological entrepreneurship]. J Health Admin 2021; 24: 9-20. (in Persian)
12. 12. Kumar P, Kumar A, Sankar JG. Service quality of health tourism in India: A structural equation modelling approach. Solid State Technol 2020; 63: 1187-1191.
13. 13. Ghasemi P, Mehdiabadi A, Spulbar C, Birau R. Ranking of sustainable medical tourism destinations in Iran: An integrated approach using fuzzy SWARA-PROMETHEE. Sustainability 2021; 13: 683.
14. 14. Ushakov DS, Yushkevych OO, Ovander NL, Tkachuk HY, Vyhovskyi VH. The strategy of Thai medical services promotion at foreign markets and development of medical tourism. Geo J Tourism Geosites 2019; 27: 1429-1438.
15. 15. Taheri B, Chalmers D, Wilson J, Arshed N. Would you really recommend it? Antecedents of word-of-mouth in medical tourism. Tourism Management 2021; 83: 104209.
16. 16. Boguszewicz-Kreft M, Kuczamer-Kłopotowska S, Kozłowski A. The role and importance of perceived risk in medical tourism. Applying the theory of planned behaviour. Plos One 2022; 17: e0262137.
17. 17. Firman A, Wang Y-Y, Moslehpour M. The critical factors selection to develop Indonesia as a medical tourism country- as an example of AHP. ICEBA 2021: 7th International Conference on E-Business and Applications. February 2021. Singapore.
18. 18. Seo BR, Park S-H. Policies to promote medical tourism in Korea: A narrative review. Iran J Public Health 2018; 47: 1077-1083.
19. 19. Lovelock B, Lovelock K. “We had a ball as long as you kept taking your painkillers” just how much tourism is there in medical tourism? Experiences of the patient tourist. Tourism Management 2018; 69: 145-154.
20. 20. Yu J, Seo J, Hyun SS. Attributes of medical tourism destination brands: Case study of the Korean medical tourism market. J Travel Tourism Market 2021; 38: 107-121.
21. 21. Chaulagain S, Jahromi MF, Fu X. Americans' intention to visit Cuba as a medical tourism destination: A destination and country image perspective. Tourism Management Perspect 2021; 40: 100900.
22. 22. Karimi Zarchi MK, Jabbari A, Hatam N, Bastani P, Shafaghat T, Fazelzadeh O. Strategic analysis of Shiraz medical tourism industry: A mixed method study. Galen Med J 2018; 7: e1021.
23. 23. Kilavuz E. Medical tourism competition: The case of Turkey. Int Journal of Health Manag and Tourism 2018; 3: 42-58.
Send email to the article author
| Rights and permissions | |
 |
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. |
